Sponsored By
An organization or individual has paid for the creation of this work but did not approve or review it.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Minnesota's Tadd Lake a pilot site for nanobubble technology

The Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District is working with the technology's owner, Moleaer, to demonstrate the potential to improve water quality.

Modern technology still requires grunt work as, from left, Jon Morales, Dan Coughlin, Chris Stephan and Erin Vruwink join forces to connect an intake line for the nanobubble system on Tadd Lake on July 3, 2024. Morales, Coughlin and Vruwink are with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District and Stephan is with Moleaer, owner of the system and its patented technology.
Modern technology still requires grunt work as, from left, Jon Morales, Dan Coughlin, Chris Stephan and Erin Vruwink join forces to connect an intake line for the nanobubble system on Tadd Lake on July 3, 2024. Morales, Coughlin and Vruwink are with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District and Stephan is with Moleaer, owner of the system and its patented technology.
Tom Cherveny / West Central Tribune

ATWATER — A small lake once popular for swimming and fishing is now the site of a pilot project that hopes to revive local recreation.

Nanobubble technology is now at work oxygenating the waters of Tadd Lake in Atwater, Minnesota, roughly 85 miles west of the Twin Cities.

ADVERTISEMENT

Staff with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District and a representative of Moleaer, a Los Angeles, California-based company that owns the technology, activated the system on July 3. It will run for approximately three months as a pilot project to demonstrate the ability of this technology to reverse the eutrophication that has made many lakes unsuitable for recreational use.

“This could be an inflection point for the area,” said Dan Coughlin, district administrator for the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District. He’s hopeful that the demonstration on the 10-acre lake will put to rest any lingering doubts about nanobubble technology.

The watershed district is working with the city of New London in hopes of securing funding to install a larger nanobubble system in the community’s Mill Pond.

Jon Morales in stern and Andy Johnson in the bow, program managers with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District, prepare to pull out the intake line for the Moleaer nano bubble system on Tadd Lake in Atwater on July 3, 2024.
Jon Morales, in stern, and Andy Johnson, in the bow, program managers with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District, prepare to pull out the intake line for the Moleaer nanobubble system on Tadd Lake in Atwater on July 3, 2024.
Tom Cherveny / West Central Tribune

For decades, the Mill Pond has been the source of foul-smelling hydrogen sulfide emissions after ice-out in the spring. A lack of oxygen in the water under the winter ice and the century-long buildup of phosphorus and other nutrients in the sediment are to blame. Bacteria that consume the nutrients in the absence of oxygen produce the unhealthy gas.

What’s known as cultural eutrophication, or the hastened buildup of nutrient-rich sediment due to human land practices and activities, has proven to be the bane of Tadd Lake, as well. Its bottom has become a soft muck, and its water is filled with pea soup-like algae and thick mats of aquatic vegetation.

Before the nanobubble system was installed, the watershed district contracted with Lakes Aquatic Weed Removal of Orr, Minnesota, to use an “underwater lawn mower” to remove as much of the lake’s aquatic vegetation as possible. Reducing the organic load in the lake prior to the start of the nanobubble system gives it a jump start, Coughlin explained.

Chris Stephan with Moleaer explains the heart of the nano bubble system installed July 3, 2024 on Tadd Lake in Atwater. Diffusers in the generator shown above shears off nano bubbles as water runs through it, making it possible to infuse oxygen rich water into Tadd Lake. With neutral buoyancy, the nano bubbles make it possible to saturate the water column with oxygen, blanking the bottom sediment as well.
Chris Stephan with Moleaer explains the heart of the nanobubble system installed July 3, 2024, on Tadd Lake in Atwater. Diffusers in the generator shown above shear off nanobubbles as water runs through it, making it possible to infuse oxygen-rich water into Tadd Lake. With neutral buoyancy, the nanobubbles make it possible to saturate the water column with oxygen, blanking the bottom sediment as well.
Tom Cherveny / West Central Tribune

The owners of Lakes Aquatic Weed Removal devoted more than two days — despite flooding back home that kept some of their employees from helping — to removing over 40 truckloads of biomass.

ADVERTISEMENT

The best is now to come. Chris Stephan, a Minnesota native and global director of sales of Moleaer, said residents in Atwater should begin seeing the lake’s water quality improve day by day through the summer months ahead.

It may be a pilot project here, but Stephan said the company’s technology has literally proven itself across the globe. It has more than 1,000 installations in 55 countries.

The system includes a large water pump, an oxygen concentrator, and the company’s patented nanobubble generator. Oxygen is infused into water pumped from Tadd Lake, and the water is run through diffusers in the nanobubble generator. As the water runs through it, the diffusers shear off the nanobubbles.

The oxygen- and nanobubble-rich water is pumped into the lake at the rate of 1,000 gallons a minute. Nanobubbles are microscopic, virus-sized and have no buoyancy. Because of it, the oxygen evenly saturates the entire water column, the bottom included, according to Stephan.

That’s critical, as standard aeration systems do not blanket the bottom sediment with oxygen since their bubbles rise rapidly to the surface.

Jon Morales, left, and Andy Johnson, right, program managers with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District, prepare to submerge the water intake for the Moleaer nano bubble system on Tadd Lake in Atwater on July 3, 2024.
Jon Morales, left, and Andy Johnson, program managers with the Middle Fork Crow River Watershed District, prepare to submerge the water intake for the Moleaer nanobubble system on Tadd Lake in Atwater on July 3, 2024.
Tom Cherveny / West Central Tribune

When the bottom is supplied with oxygen by a nanobubble system, the bacteria in the sediment go to work eating the nutrients. A soft bottom of muck should turn firm. The consumption of phosphorus will starve the algae, clearing the water overall, according to Stephan.

Nanobubble technology has widespread industrial uses, but Moleaer has the only system that scales up for use in bodies of water, according to Stephan. “This is our fastest-growing market system,” he said. “We treat lakes like this all over the world.”

ADVERTISEMENT

More Northland Outdoors:
Snowy owl sightings have increased and experts urge caution.
Minnesota Department of Natural Resources report for the week of Feb. 3, 2025.
Itasca Waters' Water Wisdom series continues at noon on Thursday, Feb. 6, with "Invasive Freshwater Jellyfish — Why Are They Increasing So Fast and What Do They Do in Lakes?"
Siera Romine took home the top prize of a brand new truck on Saturday, Feb. 1, with her 5.85-pound walleye.
Knowing what to leave out of a story – as opposed to just opening the notebook and letting the words spill out – can be more difficult than knowing what to include.
Kittson Central herd unchanged from 2023; Caribou-Vita and Grygla herds down slightly.
The official Hall of Fame enshrinement will take place Friday, Sept. 26, 2025, at the Rice Creek Hunting, Rec and Event Center in Little Falls, Minnesota.
The new system now will be rolled out later this year. The DNR initially had planned a March 2025 launch date.
This time around, the trio of snowmobiling seniors is heading for the coast of Newfoundland and Labrador.
Retired teacher Larry Weber, of Barnum, is the author of “Butterflies of the North Woods" and “Spiders of the North Woods," among other books. Reach him via Katie Rohman at krohman@duluthnews.com.

Jon Morales and Andy Johnson, program managers with the watershed district, have been analyzing the effectiveness of the systems. They’ve also made this venture an outdoor laboratory by collecting and continuing to collect a wide range of data on water conditions in the lake.

There’s a monitor upstream of Tadd Lake in a small pond recording data on the condition of the water in this control pond. There is another in Tadd Lake itself, likewise monitoring the changes to come.

Over 40 truck loads of biomass were removed from Tadd Lake by Lakes Aquatic Weed Removal of Orr to prepare the lake as a pilot project for the nano bubble technology. The biomass is piled on June 20, 2024 before being removed for proper disposal.
More than 40 truckloads of biomass were removed from Tadd Lake by Lakes Aquatic Weed Removal of Orr, Minnesota, to prepare the lake as a pilot project for the nanobubble technology. The biomass is piled up June 20, 2024, before being removed for proper disposal.
Contributed

Coughlin has made this technology the focus of his own research for a master’s program. In simple terms, he said it is about “giving Mother Nature an opportunity to catch her breath and restore a natural balance.”

It will cost a few thousand dollars a month for electricity to operate the system in Tadd Lake, according to Stephan.

If it proves its worth, the watershed district believes it could be put to work in other area waters where excessive nutrient loads are impacting water quality. Diamond Lake, which has seen algae issues due to cultural eutrophication, is among the candidates.

This is a look on June 17, 2023 at the condition of Tadd Lake prior to the removal of over 40 truck loads of biomass. The lake was covered by duck weed and had blooms of algae and aquatic vegetation. Removing the organic matter gives the nano bubble system a jump start on the clean up operation.
The condition of Tadd Lake is shown June 17, 2023, prior to the removal of more than 40 truck loads of biomass. The lake was covered by duckweed and had blooms of algae and aquatic vegetation. Removing the organic matter gives the nanobubble system a jump start on the cleanup operation.
Contributed

Tom Cherveny is a regional and outdoors reporter for the West Central Tribune.
He has been a reporter with the West Central Tribune since 1993.

Cherveny can be reached via email at tcherveny@wctrib.com or by phone at 320-214-4335.
Conversation

ADVERTISEMENT

What To Read Next
Get Local

ADVERTISEMENT